10 signs someone is deeply attracted to you but trying to play it cool

Reading the signs of attraction can be like deciphering a secret code. Especially when someone is really into you, but they’re trying to play it cool.

The trick is understanding the subtle signals. Those little hints that say, “Hey, I’m really into you”, without making it too obvious.

In this article, I’m going to share with you 10 signs that someone is deeply attracted to you but doing their best to keep it low-key.

Let’s get started.

1) They’re always around

First things first, a person who is deeply attracted to you will always seem to be around. Even when they’re trying to play it cool, they just can’t help but gravitate towards you.

This isn’t about stalking or being creepy. It’s more subtle than that. It’s about them finding reasons to be in the same room as you, or always ending up in the same group conversation.

If you notice someone constantly in your vicinity, even when there’s no apparent reason for them to be there, it might be a sign that they’re into you. They’re playing it cool and not making it obvious, but their attraction is pulling them your way.

This is only the first sign. You’ll need more than just this to confirm someone’s feelings. But it’s a start!

2) They remember the small details

Now, this one hit me right in the feels when I first noticed it.

I had this coworker who was always around, but we were just friends, or so I thought. Then one day, she mentioned something about my favorite band, which I didn’t even remember telling her.

She remembered not just that, but my favorite song, the concert I attended two years back, and even the band t-shirt I once wore to a casual Friday at work.

It wasn’t just with music. She remembered my favorite coffee blend, the quirky quotes from my favorite movie, and even the stories I shared about my childhood pet.

That’s when it hit me. She wasn’t just ‘around’, she was paying attention to the small details about me. It was one of those signs that she was into me but playing it cool.

3) Their body language is telling

Body language is one of the most powerful forms of non-verbal communication. It’s often unconscious and can reveal our true feelings, even when we’re trying to keep them under wraps.

When someone is attracted to you, their body language might give them away. They might lean in when you’re talking, make a lot of eye contact, or frequently touch their face or neck during the conversation.

People are generally pretty good at gauging others’ interest based on non-verbal cues. So even if they’re playing it cool verbally, their body language might be revealing their true feelings.

When you’re interacting with this person, pay close attention to their body language. It might just be telling you what they’re trying so hard to hide.

4) They initiate contact

Now, this can be a tricky one, especially if the person is trying to play it cool. But often, when someone is deeply attracted to you, they will find reasons to initiate contact.

This doesn’t necessarily mean physical touch, although that can be a part of it. It could be reaching out via text or phone call, starting conversations, or suggesting plans to hang out.

They may play it off as casual or coincidental, but the fact that they’re making an effort to connect with you can be a pretty clear sign of their attraction. They want to talk to you, spend time with you and get to know you better.

Take note of who’s initiating. If it’s them more often than not, they might just be into you but trying not to make it too obvious.

5) They show genuine interest in your life

When someone is deeply attracted to you, they want to know more about you. Not just the surface-level stuff, but your dreams, aspirations, fears, and even your most mundane day-to-day activities.

They’ll ask about your day and genuinely listen to your responses. They’ll remember what you’ve told them and follow up on it. It could be as simple as asking how your big work presentation went or how your weekend trip with friends was.

This interest in your life goes beyond just polite conversation. It’s a sign that they care about you as a person and are interested in understanding you better.

If someone is showing this level of interest in your life while trying to play it cool, it’s a good sign they’re more than just casually interested in you.

6) They support you through thick and thin

There’s something incredibly attractive about a person who stands by your side, even when the going gets tough. That’s not just friendship; it’s a sign of deep attraction.

They’re there for you after a hard day, offering comfort and understanding. They celebrate your victories and encourage you when you’re down. They’re not just around for the good times; they’re there for the hard times as well.

This kind of emotional support isn’t given freely by everyone. It requires a deep level of care and attraction. So if you notice this person standing by your side, through thick and thin, it could be a sign they’re deeply attracted to you but trying to keep it cool.

Actions speak louder than words, and being there for someone in times of need is one of the most heartfelt actions one can take.

7) They open up to you

Once, I met someone who seemed to have an impenetrable wall around them. They were always polite and friendly, but never really opened up about their thoughts and feelings.

Then, one day, they started sharing. It started with small things, like their love for old-school vinyl records or their fear of spiders. And then it moved on to deeper stuff – their hopes, dreams, and even insecurities.

The change was gradual and almost imperceptible. But as they started opening up to me, I realized that this was a sign of deep attraction.

When someone trusts you enough to share their inner thoughts and feelings, it’s a clear sign they’re attracted to you. They’re letting you see a part of them that’s usually hidden – a vulnerable side.

8) They tease you

This might seem confusing at first. If someone is deeply attracted to you, why would they tease you?

Well, it’s actually a classic sign of attraction. It’s a playful way to establish a connection, show familiarity and keep the conversation light-hearted. It’s like they’re saying, “I know you well enough to tease you, and I’m comfortable enough with our relationship to do so.”

Of course, this doesn’t mean hurtful or demeaning teasing. We’re talking about playful, friendly banter here.

9) They’re always happy to see you

This one might seem pretty obvious, but it’s actually a pretty reliable sign of attraction.

When someone is deeply attracted to you, they’ll be genuinely happy whenever they see you. Even if they’re trying to play it cool, their excitement could show in their smile, their energy, or the sparkle in their eyes.

They might quickly try to hide it and regain their composure, but that initial reaction can be very telling.

Take note of how this person reacts when they see you. If they seem genuinely happy and excited, it’s a good sign they’re attracted to you but trying to keep it under wraps.

10) They show consistency

The most important sign to look out for is consistency. All the signs above could potentially be one-off instances or due to other factors. But when someone consistently shows these signs over an extended period, it’s a strong indicator of deep attraction.

Consistency shows that it’s not just a passing phase or a casual interest. It means they’re into you, and they’ve been into you for a while.

Keep an eye out for consistent behavior. If they’re always around, constantly initiating contact, showing genuine interest in your life, supporting you through thick and thin, opening up to you, teasing you, and always happy to see you, then chances are they’re deeply attracted to you but trying hard to play it cool.

Final thoughts: Attraction is more than meets the eye

When someone is deeply attracted to you but trying to play it cool, these signs can become even more subtle. But with a keen eye and an open heart, you can learn to read these signals and understand what they’re really saying.

Every person is unique. What holds true for one might not hold true for another. It’s always important to communicate openly and honestly about feelings.

In the words of Maya Angelou, “People will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.” If someone continually makes you feel special and valued, chances are they’re deeply attracted to you.

So, take a moment to reflect. Have you noticed these signs in someone around you? Could there be a hidden attraction lurking beneath their cool exterior? Only time – and a little courage – can truly reveal the answers.

Neuroscientist reveals a new way to manifest more financial abundance

Breakthrough Columbia study confirms the brain region is 250 million years old, the size of a walnut and accessible inside your brain right now.

Learn More

Picture of Tina Fey

Tina Fey

I've ridden the rails, gone off track and lost my train of thought. I'm writing to try and find it again. Hope you enjoy the journey with me.

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

Neuroscience shows people who truly thrive never apologize for these 8 things

Neuroscience shows people who truly thrive never apologize for these 8 things

Jeanette Brown

If you relate to these 8 signs, psychology says you have above average intelligence levels

If you relate to these 8 signs, psychology says you have above average intelligence levels

The Vessel

People who listen more than they speak often display these 7 distinctive traits

People who listen more than they speak often display these 7 distinctive traits

The Vessel

9 little things you do now that would’ve baffled your younger self

9 little things you do now that would’ve baffled your younger self

The Vessel

9 unique relationship behaviors of men who are emotionally stable and self‑aware, according to psychology

9 unique relationship behaviors of men who are emotionally stable and self‑aware, according to psychology

The Vessel

7 things people do when your growth makes them uncomfortable

7 things people do when your growth makes them uncomfortable

The Vessel