The ChallengeBy Deborah Gage | Posted 2003-11-01 Email Print
Re-Thinking HR: What Every CIO Needs to Know About Tomorrow's Workforce
The legislative rush to curb telemarketing and spam makes it hard to sell electronically. Even if you keep your data clean, no silver bullet prevents lawsuits.
The challenge for companies is to find legal ways of selling to customers by phone or e-mail without harassing them. That means updating databases to exclude specific names from marketing pitches, based on policies that differ across statesand even countries.
"A company trying to make all its databases comply with all the rules has an overwhelming process task," says Bill Blundon, chief marketing officer of Extraprise, a Boston-based technology-services firm with several multinational clients. "People are really scrambling to figure out what to do."
Some companies, gun-shy for fear that anything they say could be used against them in court, are even refusing to discuss their plans to comply with laws to stop telemarketing and e-mail abuses. Case in point: Allstate Insurance. The company went mum after the Institute for International Researcha company that holds industry conferencescirculated an e-mail interview with Allstate vice president John Hershberger characterizing Allstate as unprepared for Do Not Call. An Allstate spokeswoman says the company is complying with the law and has no further comment.
"We brought this on ourselvesit's all telemarketers' faults," says Scott Stawski, vice president of the marketing consultancy Inforte. "We must find less-intrusive ways to sell."
Analysts and consultants say it's difficult to prepare for these laws because they raise enough questions to make court challenges inevitable. For example, companies are puzzling over the meaning of California's requirement that residents cannot be e-mailed without "a clear and conspicuous request" for recipients' consent.
A seminar on Do Not Call held in London last month by Extraprise drew hundreds of peopleincluding lawyers networking to see how well peers understood the laws. Extraprise is advising all clientseven those who do business only in the U.S.to abide by the European Union's privacy laws, which are being mimicked in much of the world. The E.U. starts from the premise that customers own their personal information and businesses need their permission to use it. The E.U.'s latest privacy directivewhich member countries were required to adopt on Oct. 31prohibits e-mail marketing without consent and establishes a private right-of-action similar to California's.
"[These laws] get to the fundamental nature of our society," says Bill Blundon. "The U.S. has been fairly generous with freedom of speech, but now a lot of tactical decisions are changing the philosophy of how business communicates with the world."