Symbol Technologies: Takes A LickingBy Joshua Weinberger | Posted 2003-05-01 Email Print
Re-Thinking HR: What Every CIO Needs to Know About Tomorrow's Workforce
Durability certainly matterswhether it's a handheld device that can withstand a four-foot drop onto concrete, or the reputation of a company suddenly facing intense SEC scrutiny.SYMBOL TECHNOLOGIES
1 Symbol Plaza
Holtsville, NY 11742
Chairman, Chief Scientist
Credited with more than 150 patents, he cofounded the company in 1975. Was a program manager on a key NASA Apollo project in the 1960s.
SVP, Mobile Computing and Scanning
Previously an intellectual-property lawyer, he joined in 1991.
Handhelds, running on Palm, Pocket PC or Windows CE, include the PDT 8000 and the PPT 8800, which perform bar-code scanning and wireless communication; also offers mobile peripherals such as scanners and printers.
Takes a Licking
Durability certainly matterswhether it's a handheld device that can withstand a four-foot drop onto concrete, or the reputation of a company suddenly facing intense SEC scrutiny.
Symbol's devices are renowned for their rugged construction, which makes them well-suited for the rough-and-tumble world of the direct-store-delivery model. (That's how they're employed by PepsiCosee Case Dissection, p. 34.) Still, when a former exec is sued by the SEC for fraudulently pumping up sales revenuesSymbol is restating its results from 1999 to 2002customers might be forgiven for having a few doubts.
Rob McClellan, for one, of TaylorMade-adidas Golf, says he's "not overly concerned" about the SEC flap. "The technology is stable; one way or another, that will continue to live." It's no wonder McClellan has strong feelings: his recent deployment has had sales reps realizing a 50% reduction in time spent on customer calls, and a 25% increase overall in productivity.
Similarly, Millstone's Dave Ziegler says his company has tabulated the benefits of its 350 Symbol units (mostly the 1700 model), "but not on a hard number basis." Instead, "we're really focused on reliability: less downtime for the sales associates, more time to focus on their delivering and selling responsibilities." About 20% of Millstone's units are the 1800 model, which, with a later operating system and expanded memory, was necessary "where we have very heavy usage of a large volume of data, and needed heavier processing power."
Buying rival Telxon, in 2000, gave Symbol an expanded client baseand gave some Telxon users a few headaches. "The Telxon acquisition had its downsides," says Giant Eagle's Robert P. Garrity, including confusion over billing issues and key contacts.
Last year, Totes Isotoner switched 35 of its 100 Symbol units from handhelds to wrist-mounted devicesand director of distribution Doug Baker estimates it brought a 20% increase in productivity, giving workers "two hands to work with instead of one." But product satisfaction isn't the same as a strong personal relationshipconsultant Manhattan Associates managed the deployment. "We don't work directly with Symbol," Baker says, beyond warranty and repairs. For the U.S. Postal Service's Robert Otto, that was the rough patch. "The quality and turnaround time for parts' repair [was] not the best," he says, but Symbol's continuous enhancements to the product compensated.
Most importantly, TaylorMade's McClellan says, his sales reps "love the thingit fits in your hand when it's open, and straps on the side so you don't lose it; you drop it, and it's undamaged." Durable, maybebut not irreplaceable. "There are products of equal capabilities available," says Giant Eagle's Garrity. But nothing, he says, can touch "the innovation that Symbol brings to the industry."