Intelligence - Baseline
Home arrow Intelligence arrow Prudish Apple Stifles Innovation

Prudish Apple Stifles Innovation


Share

By Edward Cone on 2010-02-25

Apple's decision to remove sexy apps from the iPhone App Store has kicked up a furor -- and not just among people who want to look at nudie pics on the go. The real danger goes way beyond porn; as big brains like Jonathan Zittrain and Dave Winer have been saying for some time, too much control limits creativity and innovation.

 

  • 1. Unwritten Rules
    Apple's standards are vague, which can discourage developers from investing time and money.
  • 2. Uneven Playing Field
    Some racy apps are axed, some not. Who gets the advantage, and why?
  • 3. Competitors Beware
    The leverage a popular phone and App Store provide Apple against its rivals is enormous.
  • 4. Walled Garden
    Zittrain: "Generative" techs like PC and Net allow innovation from all directions. App Store, not so much.
  • 5. Big Brother Redux
    Zittrain: "Jobs takes a cut, and reserves the right to reject any software he doesn't like, for any reason...That's the point where I say, Yikes."
  • 6. Minister of Culture
    Dave Winer: "Big pieces of our culture flow through one company's servers. [I worry that it] takes an interest in the ideas that are expressed, shutting off certain ideas..."
  • 7. Whose Device Is It Anyway?
    Don't like sexy apps, or silly ones? Don't buy them.