Columbus Debunker Sets Sights on Leonardo da Vinci (
Page 1 of 2 )
Gavin Menzies sparked headlines across the globe with the claim that Chinese sailors reached America 70 years before Christopher Columbus. Now he says a Chinese fleet brought encyclopedias of technology undiscovered by the West to Italy in 1434.LONDON (Reuters) -
Leonardo da Vinci's drawings of machines are uncannily similar to
Chinese originals and were undoubtedly derived from them, a British
amateur historian says in a newly-published book.
Gavin Menzies sparked headlines across the globe in 2002 with the
claim that Chinese sailors reached America 70 years before Christopher
Columbus.
Now he says a Chinese fleet brought encyclopedias of technology
undiscovered by the West to Italy in 1434, laying the foundation for
the engineering marvels such as flying machines later drawn by Italian
polymath Leonardo.
"Everything known to the Chinese by the year 1430 was brought to
Venice," said Menzies, a retired Royal Navy submarine commander, in an
interview at his north London home.
From Venice, a Chinese ambassador went to Florence and presented the material to Pope Eugenius IV, Menzies says.
"I argue in the book that this was the spark that really ignited the
renaissance and that Leonardo and (Italian astronomer) Galileo built on
what was brought to them by the Chinese.
"Leonardo basically redrew everything in three dimensions, which made a vast improvement."
If accepted, the claim would force an "agonizing reappraisal of the
Eurocentric view of history", Menzies says in his book "1434: The Year
A Magnificent Chinese Fleet Sailed To Italy and Ignited The
Renaissance".
NONSENSE
The urbane 70-year-old sold more than a million copies of his first
book, "1421", which argued Chinese sailors mapped the world in the
early 1400s shortly before abandoning global seafaring.
His theories are dismissed as nonsense by many academics -- Menzies
says Chinese fleets reached Australia and New Zealand as well as
America before European explorers -- but have gained an international
following among readers.
"This whole fantasy about Europe discovering the world is just nonsense," said Menzies.
In his latest book -- published in the United States in June and
this month in Britain -- Menzies says four ships from the same Chinese
expeditions reached Venice, bringing with them world maps, astronomical
charts and encyclopedias far in advance of anything available in Europe
at the time.
Menzies says Leonardo's designs for machines can be traced back to this transfer of Chinese knowledge.
Leonardo, born in 1452, is perhaps best known for his enigmatic
"Mona Lisa" portrait of a woman in Paris's Louvre Museum, but he also
left journals filled with intricate engineering and anatomical
illustrations.
Menzies says designs for gears, waterwheels and other devices
contained in Chinese encyclopedias reached Leonardo after being copied
and modified by his Italian antecedents Taccola and Francesco di
Giorgio.
To support his argument, Menzies publishes drawings of siege
weapons, mills and pumps from a 1313 Chinese agricultural treatise, the
Nung Shu, and from other pre-1430 Chinese books, next to apparently
similar illustrations by Leonardo, Di Giorgio and Taccola.
"By comparing Leonardo's drawings with the Nung Shu we have verified
that each element of a machine superbly illustrated by Leonardo had
previously been illustrated by the Chinese in a much simpler manual,"
Menzies writes.
"It's very suggestive, very interesting, but the hard work remains
to be done," said Martin Kemp, Professor of the History of Art at
Oxford University and author of books on Leonardo.
"He (Menzies) says something is a copy just because they look
similar. He says two things are almost identical when they are not,"
Kemp said.
"It's not strong on historical method," he added. But Kemp said he
would look out for any signs that Leonardo had access to Chinese
material, directly or indirectly, when studying his manuscripts in
future.