A meeting to hammer
out a consensus on whether a Microsoft document format
should become an international standard descended into near
chaos this week.
FRANKFURT/BRUSSELS, Feb 29 (Reuters) - A meeting to hammer
out a consensus on whether a Microsoft document format
should become an international standard descended into near
chaos this week, people close to the meeting told Reuters.
The closed-door meeting hosted by the International
Organisation for Standardisation (ISO) in Geneva was supposed
to help ISO members address concerns that prevented them from
approving the document format as an ISO standard in September.
Instead, the ballot resolution meeting became bogged down
in bureaucracy as the delegates struggled with more than a
thousand points of order, as well as the 6,000 pages of code
that define Microsoft's Office Open XML (OOXML) format.
"They spent an entire day discussing how they would go
about the process. With the massive amount of work they have to
do, most are frustrated that they spent 20 percent of their
time determining how they were going to vote," said one
source.
"There just is not enough time to cover the large number of
problems in the document. I believe that a lot of the nations
are frustrated with the process in general."
Microsoft Corp hopes ratification of OOXML, the default
file-saving format of Microsoft Office 2007, will improve its
chances of winning contracts from public-sector clients fearful
their archives could become hostage to a proprietary format.
Opponents argue that introducing a rival to the already
ISO-approved Open Document Format (ODF) defeats the purpose of
having standards and say the complexity of OOXML makes full
translation of OOXML documents into other formats impossible.
"It's like Betamax and VHS or or Blue Ray and HD-DVD," said
the source, referring to battles for home video standards that
held up the industry until one prevailed.
Microsoft has argued that multiple standards are better
than one and says OOXML's higher specifications make it more
useful than ODF.
"The deep engagement and steadfast commitment exhibited by
national bodies participating in the consideration of the DIS
29500 (Open XML) specification illustrates their strong desire
to rigorously examine and improve this widely adopted
technology," Microsoft's head of interoperability and
standards, Tom Robertson, said in a statement.
Shane Coughlan, the legal coordinator of the Free Software
Foundation Europe -- which opposes the attempt to make OOXML an
ISO standard -- said after meeting some of the delegates this
week that they seemed to be faced with an impossible task.
"Everyone said they were very busy, although of course it
would not have been appropriate for them to comment on what
they were doing. The question is whether all the comments can
reasonably be reviewed within one week," he told Reuters.
"We're talking an awful lot of concerns. I think there will
be a lot more national discussions when the ballot resolution
meeting is through."
After the meeting, the 37 national delegations attending,
as well as the 50 others who took part in the original vote
last year will have until March 29 to adjust their positions,
giving Microsoft another shot at a two-thirds majority.
Search engine giant Google Inc, which uses the
open ODF standard in its document and spreadsheet applications,
has also lent its weight to the anti-Microsoft camp.
"Our engineers conducted an independent analysis of the
OOXML specification and found several areas of concern," Zaheda
Bhorat of Google's open source team wrote in a blog welcoming
the initial vote rejecting fast-track approval of OOXML.
Google cited inadequate time to review the specifications,
undocumented features of OOXML that would prevent other vendors
implementing it and the dependence of OOXML on other Microsoft
proprietary formats as some of the arguments against it.
Google, which may face a stronger Microsoft as a rival in
Internet search and other services if Microsoft's bid to buy
Yahoo Inc succeeds, has also embraced open software
standards in a cellphone platform it is developing.
The Free Software Foundation's Coughlan said the
difficulties of resolving the issue within the ISO framework
illustrated a growing awareness that the implications of such
decisions went far beyond the software industry.
"In the last few years, we've seen a lot more awareness of
the digital world as a key aspect of society ... We're not just
looking at the traditional economic powers asking questions or
being involved. This is very broad," he said. "The
standardisation process itself has been tested quite
extensively by this."
(Editing by Andre Grenon)
© Reuters 2008 All rights reserved