History shows that a recession has helped the dollar. NEW YORK (Reuters)
- A U.S. recession may be just what the U.S. dollar needs to trigger a
rebound, after a long slide in the past year or more, if historical
trends hold true.
That may sound counterintuitive but in the past when the outlook for
the economy was at its worst and interest rates were at a low, the
dollar has typically already begun to rally.
"A U.S. recession is a positive for the dollar in the sense that
expectations bottom with respect to the U.S. growth outlook and U.S.
interest rates eventually bottom," said Michael Woolfolk, senior
currency strategist at Bank of New York Mellon in New York.
"Expectations for strong U.S. growth and higher U.S. rates provide
support for the greenback as trade and investment flows provide
fundamental underpinning for a dollar rally," Woolfolk said.
Though the definition of recession can vary, during the acknowledged
U.S. economic downturn of late 2000 into 2001 the New York Board of
Trade's dollar index .DXY peaked in July 2001 at around 121.
By then the Federal Reserve had already cut the benchmark overnight
interbank lending rate from 6.5 percent in May 2000 to 3.75 percent in
May 2001.
While the conventional thinking is that lower interest rates reduce
the attractiveness of dollar-denominated securities the dollar only
began to fall from that peak as the Fed continued to cut rates to a
40-year low of 1.0 percent in June 2003.
That helped send the dollar index .DXY to around 85 in early 2004,
according to Reuters data, even though the U.S. economy had been
growing from the third quarter of 2001.
But by May 2004, the dollar index had recovered to around 92, with
the gain all prior to the Fed beginning a monetary policy tightening
cycle which lasted from June 2004 until June 2006.
In fact, in four of the past five US economic recessions going back
to the early 1970s, the dollar has been higher four months after the
downturn ended than it had been four months before it began. In the one
exception, the 1990-91 recession, the greenback was essentially
unchanged over such a span.
What does that mean for the U.S. dollar in 2008?
"Were the dollar to follow the example of 2002-04, the dollar index
would not put in a bottom until the recovery were clearly back on
track," said Bank of New York Mellon's Woolfolk.
So the sooner the recession is over, the sooner dollar investors can enjoy a sustained rally.
Though there are multiple variables at play and U.S. rates relative
to those elsewhere in the industrialized world will also play their
part, Woolfolk places the potential for the dollar to begin to recover
across the board no sooner than year end.
Joseph Quinlan, chief market strategist at Bank of America's Global
Wealth & Investment Management in New York agrees with Woolfolk
that a U.S. recession will signal a dollar recovery but places that
recovery closer in time.
"Sometime in the second quarter, the markets may come to believe
that the U.S. economy will be the "first-in, first-out" in terms of
recession/global economic slowdown, suggesting higher U.S. interest
rates down the road," said Quinlan. "That is bullish for the buck."
The Federal Reserve has cut the benchmark rate by 300 basis points
to 2.25 percent in the easing cycle that began last September with
investors still debating whether the rate will be below 2 percent when
the cycle ends.
Part of the problem in predicting when the dollar will recover is
that most "buy" signals will only be apparent after the recession is
over, said Dustin Reid, senior currency strategist at ABN AMRO in
Chicago.
"There is not ever a clear signal," Reid said. "Every macro-economic cycle is different."
The Federal Reserve shifting to a neutral stance could be a signal
as could large fund flows into the dollar, Reid said, but since most
data is not real time, most signals are after the fact.
Looking at recessions since 1974, Marco Spaltro, London-based
currency economist at IDEAglobal, said "the market has already
discounted the possibility of a recession in the U.S., and we are close
to a buy signal for the dollar."
That's despite no contraction in the U.S. economy since the third
quarter of 2001 and the economy still eking out a 0.6 percent gain in
the fourth quarter of 2007.
All of which may lead investors to conclude that the only sure bet
is when the recession is clearly in the past, and it is equally clear
the dollar is on an upswing.
(Reporting by Nick Olivari)
© Reuters 2008 All rights reserved