Post/Riposte: Nucleus Research Doesn't Take Siebel at Its Word

By Baselinemag  |  Posted 2002-10-08 Email Print this article Print
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

After a research firm challenged the validity of Siebel Systems' customer testimonials, a war of words broke out.

Siebel Systems, not surprisingly, used customer testimonials on its Web site. Then Nucleus Research Inc., came along. The Wellesley, Mass., firm contacted 66 "reference customers" on Siebel's site and heard back from 23. Here's what they had to say.
"Siebel Customers Report Exceptional ROI Gains"

—Siebel corporate advertisement
9/26/2002

 
"61% of Siebel Reference Customers Report Negative ROI on Software Deployments"

—Title of Nucleus Research study
9/2002

 
"Our customers do not perceive us as an arrogant company."

—CEO Thomas Siebel
c|Net/news.com
5/20/2002

 
"They're very arrogant, very full of themselves. Their service staff is unresponsive."

—Siebel customer, Nucleus' report
9/2002

 
"This report [was] conducted on behalf of Siebel Systems by Satmetrix Systems."

—Siebel "Customer Satisfaction Report"
9/2002

 
"We took an equity interest in [Satmetrix] a couple of years ago."

—CEO Thomas Siebel
c|Net/news.com
5/20/2002

 
"We're calling everyone and asking, 'Do you still stand by this success story?' "

—Spokeswoman confirming all testimonials
removed from Siebel's site
S.F. Chronicle
9/26/2002

 
"If Nucleus is wrong, then why hide the case studies?"

—Nucleus President & CEO
Ian Campbell
9/26/2002

 
"It is not clear who [Nucleus] talked to. [The report] is anecdotal and we would not expect anyone to take it seriously."

—Siebel VP Phil Robinson
Computerwire
9/26/2002

 
"If you survey your parents and they both say they don't love you, you can't complain about the sample size."

—Nucleus VP Rebecca Wettemann, 9/26/2002

 


 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Submit a Comment

Loading Comments...
Manage your Newsletters: Login   Register My Newsletters