Are You a CIO Who Matters?By Kim S. Nash | Posted 2002-09-01 Email Print
Re-Thinking HR: What Every CIO Needs to Know About Tomorrow's Workforce
Fewer than 40 technology executives in the entire fortune 500 are paid enough to be publicly reported. Here's who made the cut
Every year, senior managers participate in a corporate beauty contestand few technology executives make the final list.
A Baseline analysis finds that only 37 chief information officers ranked among the highest paid officers of Fortune 500 companies in 2001.
Baseline's list is culled from proxy statements filed by companies that must inform their shareholders before their annual meeting who their five highest-paid officers are.
The Securities and Exchange Commission requires that disclosure, along with the names and titles of those executives. Chairmen and chief executives always make the proxy. Chief financial officers rarely miss. Who fills the other slotswhether from marketing, sales, technology or other top functionssays a lot about what a company values.
Richard Chapman, CIO at Kindred Healthcare, is the highest paid executive in the Baseline ranking, with $2.5 million in compensation for 2001.
He succeeds Leslie Tortora, the long-time CIO of securities brokerage Goldman Sachs, the highest paid for 2000 with $9.4 million in salary and bonuses. She took herself out of the running by retiring.
Chapman helps Kindred Healthcare run a $2.3 billion national network of hospitals, nursing homes and pharmacies. He must keep track of Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements, which provide 70% of Kindred's revenues.
Kindred, based in Louisville, Ky., entered Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 1999 to restructure debt. Kindred came out of bankruptcy in April 2001 and posted $52 million in profits for the year.
San Francisco-based Wells Fargo, which has the No. 2 CIO in Baseline's rankingC. Webb Edwards, who earned $1.6 millionis a company long regarded as a technology innovator. At No. 3 is Thomas Whiddon, CIO of Lowe's Companies, a $22.1 billion chain of home improvement stores based in Wilkesboro, N.C., that is second only to Home Depot. Whiddon, who has been at Lowe's for six years, received $1.4 million last year.
CIOs in general didn't see the same level of riches in 2001 as in 2000. The lion's share of most multimillion-dollar compensation packages are stock awards tied to company performance. Last year's lackluster economy dragged stock-based bonuses down. Way down.
For example, Fran Dramis, CIO of Atlanta-based telecommunications firm BellSouth, received a bonus of $4.2 million in restricted stock in 2000, but no stock last year. His package dropped from $5.5 million to $1.2 million. CIO pay overall sank in 2001 compared to 2000.
Compensation for the top 10 CIOs as revealed in proxy statements ranged from $1.1 million to $2.5 million in 2001, compared to a range of $1.1 million to $9.4 million the previous year.
A few CIOs from last year's list fell off altogether this time around.
Among them, Jean Davis of Wachovia Corp., a banking firm, wasn't there; a shuffling of executives at the bank put several new names in the proxy. Ron Gaston quit Venator Group, the athletic-wear retailer that since has been renamed Foot Locker. Terry Talley replaced Gaston as CIO. Bruce Goodman, of the Humana Inc. health-benefits firm, was displaced by the company's chief financial officer. Bill Seltzer retired as CIO of the office products retailer Office Depot.
Of course, getting your name into the proxy is not a definitive measure of CIO stature. Even if you don't make the cut, you still could be one of the top-paid technology executives in the country. For example, a CIO who makes $500,000 at one company might be one of the five highest-paid officers there and would be included in the proxy statement. But at a bigger company, a CIO's multimillion-dollar earnings might be exceeded by fiveor moreother top officers.
An analysis of the CIOs in this year's elite 7% can help guide other technology executives to the top.
First, understand that longevity counts. The short tenure of CIOstypically two to three yearscontributes to the field's poor show- ing. That is, the longer you're at a company, the more likely you are to receive a fat paycheck and bonuses.
Tortora, for example, led technology strategy at Goldman for seven years before she retired in 2001, a 45-year-old multimillionaire. Steve Mnuchin, Tortora's replacement, didn't make the company's latest proxy. He came to Goldman the same year Tortora did, but has spent most of his time in departments other than technology, which he joined in 1999.
Some of the other highest-paid CIOs have been at the same company for many years as well, including Dawn Lepore of Charles Schwab brokerage (19 years), Brian Kilcourse of Longs Drug Stores chain (19 years) and Mike Heschel of grocery retailer Kroger (11 years).
(Lepore was promoted to vice chairman of technology and administration in late 2001 and was replaced as CIO by Schwab Executive Vice President Geoff Penney.)
Know, too, that in several industries the top technology executives, even if they are corporate officers, consistently make less than other senior managers. For example, no CIOs appeared in proxies from the biggest pharmaceutical, petroleum, chemical and publishing companies in the U.S.
one more CIO dead zone: diversified financial firms, including American Express, Capital One Financial and Citigroup. The $22.3-billion American Express, for example, is widely regarded as having built a top-notch technology infrastructure. CIO Glen Salow wasn't listed in the company proxy this year, though a vice chairman, the president of the U.S. consumer group and the president of global financial services were, along with the chairman/chief executive and chief financial officer.
That doesn't mean technology isn't important, even critical, to these sorts of companies. But group presidents of geographic areas, heads of research and chief operating officers often occupy the spots that might otherwise be taken by CIOs. Top in-house lawyers and human resources leaders also sometimes end up among the five most highly compensated officers.
By contrast, some industries were favorable to CIOs this year. Electronics companies had seven CIOs listed, and firms in food manufacturing and food retail had six. Health care, specialty retail and commercial banks each had four. A critical emphasis on logistics and supply-chain issues in these industriesespecially in electronics, retail and foodlet CIOs shine.